Magical Love Story

Hi everybody! This is my first attempt at a 'story quiz' so I really hope you like it. Throughout the story, when you see _________, it means 'your name here'

So, ready to meet the guys? Will you fall for Ethan, blond and green eyes, Josh, with curly brown hair and brown eyes, or Caleb, Black hair and golden eyes? Only you can decide!

Created by: Bob Lemusa
  1. You walk in on your first day at your new school. Kids smile and laugh around you, but you have no friends... yet. You turn to take one last look at the beautiful pond just outside the door. Then someone bumps into you. You whirl around, and find a gorgeous guy blushing. "I'm so sorry," he says. "Oh, it's fine," you reply. "My name is Josh." "I'm ______," you say with a wink. But he turns and drifts into the crowd without a backward glance.
  2. You head to the Principal's office. He hands you a piece of paper and goes back to typing furiously on his computer. You head off to math, because that's what the paper says. As you walk into the room, you see that there's only one seat left. It's right next to a sexy guy, dirty blond hair and sea-blue eyes.
  3. "Hey, I'm Ethan," hottie says. You must be blushing, because you can feel your cheeks heat up. "I'm _____," you reply politely. He smiles, and you stare at his oh-so-gorgeous face. Then the teacher comes in, but Ethan seems to lean into you ever so slightly during the lesson.
  4. The morning goes by in a blur, and soon it's time for lunch. "Hey, wanna sit with me?" You whirl around, and are happy to see Ethan. He leads you to a table where Josh and some other boy with black hair covering his eyes sit. "You already know Josh, but this is Caleb," Ethan says, while glaring at Josh. Caleb looks up, and his hair falls to the side. His eyes are... golden. They widen when he sees you, and he looks down again quickly. Josh nods and smiles at you. Ethan seats you at the end of the table, and plunks himself down next to you.
  5. When lunch is over, Ethan whispers in your ear "Meet me under the willow tree by the pond after school." You nod, and go to your next class. Soon, school is over, and you run to the willow tree where Ethan leans against the trunk. He smiles at you. "So, why'd you drag me out here," you tease. "So I could be the first to do this." He grabs you and presses you against the willow tree. His warm lips press on yours. You slid your hands up to his chest, trying to put something between you, but he forces your hands back to your sides. Soon, however, the kiss enthralls you. You reach up again, but this time it's to place your hands in his blond hair, and pull him closer. Finally, you break apart, and you're breathless. Ethan runs off to somewhere, and you're alone by the pond.
  6. Caleb shows up to walk you home. He smiles at you, and suddenly you feel guilty about the kiss. Caleb grips your hand, and pulls you up from your seat under the willow tree. All to soon, your at your front porch, and Caleb leans in and...
  7. Caleb touches your nose with the tip of his finger. "You are extremely beautiful, you know,"he says softly. He pecks you on the cheek, and you walk inside slowly. When you flop onto your bed, what do you dream about?
  8. The next day, you head off to school. As you walk through the halls, some one comes up behind you. You look right to see Josh. He smiles at you, and you suddenly feel daring. You lead him into the janitor's closet, and stretch up slightly. You kiss him softly, but Josh pulls away. "No. I won't do this to you, ______," he says with tears in his eyes. He hurries out of the closet, and you follow him wondering what you did wrong. In Math, Ethan notices that you seem upset, and he tries to cheer you up. You can't help but giggle at some of the ridiculous things he does behind the teacher's back, and when the teacher whips around with a stern glare, you almost burst with laughter. Stars dance in Ethan's eyes as he acts like a proper gentle man.
  9. Mrs. Adams (the teacher) frowns, but turns back to the board. Ethan grins, and you can't help but smile, too. At lunch you sit with the guys again, but this time making sure to sit near Josh. He turns his head away. Caleb cocks his head, clearly confused. Ethan has a questioning look, like 'is this why you were sad?' You nod, and lunch goes by in silence.
  10. Finally, the long day is over, and you trudge back to your house. You notice something shiny behind a tree and squint at it. It looks like... a pair of golden eyes? You move cautiously towards it, when whatever it is leaps out. You feel a sharp pain in your neck, just before you black out.
  11. You slowly come to, and realize that you are in a room, decorated in your favorite color. You start to sit up, but you feel to woozy, and have to sit back down. "She's awake," says a soft voice from in the hall. Josh, Ethan, and Caleb walk into the room. "Are you okay, _____?" asks Josh gently, with a pointed glare at Caleb. Caleb gazes sadly at you, and takes a step back. Ethan elbowed Caleb aside, and brushed a wisp of hair out of your face. "Are you hurt, babe?" he asks. "No, I'm fine, just a little woozy," you reply. "Good," Caleb says, and both Josh and Ethan turn to glare at him. "Where... Where am I? And what am I doing here?" you ask. "Well..." Ethan trails off, and looks at Josh. "We need to tell you something."
  12. Josh takes over. "_______, we aren't normal. I'm an elf, Ethan's a werewolf, and Caleb's, well, a vampire. I know this is a lot to take in, and that you probably don't believe us, but it's true. And not only that, but you can harness all the elements... but you're the only person who can. " Josh pauses, and waits for you're reaction. You nod, slowly. "We're sorry we had to bring you here like this, but it was the only way... you lost more blood than we had expected, but-" You cut him off. "Wait, are you saying that Caleb BIT me?" Caleb turned to you, and tears glimmered in his eyes. "I'm sorry. I thought I could stop, but..." Ethan takes over. "I'll be in the room on your right, Caleb is on your left, and Josh is at the end of the hall." Then all three boys quietly leave.
  13. You venture out of your room, and knock softly on Caleb's door. When you come in, you see that all the boys are gathered there. Caleb looks up at you, and winces. "It's alright Caleb." Your words soothe him, and he relaxes. "I... I don't think I can believe you just yet," you tell the boys. "I can prove it," replies Caleb. He leans in to you, and kisses your neck. You sigh in pleasure, but stop when you feel something puncture the skin. You try to pull away, try to stop him, but you are immobilized. It feels... kind of good. You sink into a trance, and feel only Caleb's warm lips on your skin. 'More, more,' you greedily think. Caleb slowly draws away, and moves to your lips. He kisses you softly, but soon the kiss grows wilder. Caleb slides his hands up onto your neck, and you push him onto the bed. You lay there for a moment, lips presses against each other, completely in rapture. Then he pulls away, and Ethan stares bloody murder. Josh looks like he's about to cry.
  14. "I think I can believe that," you say with a smile. Then Ethan leapt up, and stalked out of the room. Josh followed shortly after. "They're ticked off, but you aren't," Caleb grins. He leans in to kiss you, and this time you're ready. you run your hands up his arms, and rest them around his neck. He scoops you up, still kissing you, and puts you on the bad again. When you break apart this time, it's for breath. Caleb smiles, but Ethan pokes his head in the door. "Breakfast," Ethan says stonily. You exit the room, but Ethan presses you against the wall. "What about our kiss?" he almost yells. "Didn't that mean anything to you? Did you desert me so completely? Are you this disloyal? Because maybe we never should have brought you here!" Fire leaps in his eyes. You press back against the wall, afraid. Then Josh walks out. "ETHAN!" he hollers. Ethan looks up, surprised. Then he looks back at you, and realized your shaking with fear. He steps back, and runs off. Josh hurries over to you. "Are you alright? Did he hurt you?" You shake your head. Josh wraps his arm around your shoulders, and together you head for breakfast.
  15. After breakfast you begin training. First you train with Caleb, working on Air. He shows you that basics, and asks you to try. You sigh, and blow him across the room. "Good, but a wee bit strong," Caleb laughs. You try again, and gently lift him off his feet. "Perfect. Now let's try something a little harder." you now have to fly yourself around the room. You jump, and wobble in the air for a few seconds, but then you crash back down. "It's a start," Caleb says.
  16. Next up you have training with Josh. He teaches you about Earth. "Try to feel every tree, every flower, every plant," he says. As he kneels down to cup a flower, you notice his ears are long and pointed. Then you turn your attention to the flower. Its petals are opening and closing rapidly. "Now you try." Josh passes you the pale pink blossom. You hold the flower delicately, and will it to open. The outer petals unfold, but the inner remain tightly pressed together. Josh tenderly takes the flower back. "I'm sorry if i hurt you earlier. I... didn't want to fall in love with you, because everyone i care about ends up dying. I didn't want, no, I couldn't take losing you, too." "Oh... oh, Josh..." as all you can say.
  17. "But now I think... maybe it will be alright," Josh says. You pause for a moment, not quite understanding until he leans in and kisses you. His kiss is as delicate as a butterfly's wing, as smooth as the sea, and you kiss him back. But your pleasure is brief, because he pulls away soon. "I... I shouldn't have done that. I'm sorry." And then he runs off again.
  18. You stumble down the hall in a bit of a trance. Ethan walks up to you. "I'm so sorry, ________. I acted impulsively. Can you ever forgive me?" "Of course! Ethan, don't beat yourself up about it!" You lea up and kiss him gently. Ethan smiles, and brings you into the living room. A fire roars in the hearth. "Summon it," Ethan says. "Umm, o-kaayy..." You strain and imagine the fire leaping to your hand, but it doesn't work. Ethan walks over to the fire. He scoops up a little bit of it and places it gently in your palm. You stare at the dancing flames, transfixed. Ethan smiles. "Just keep it burning, keep it burning." You nod, but then the fire flickers and dies. "I'm sorry, but i can't do it." "Here, maybe this will help," Ethan says. He looks down at you and cups your face in his hands. Leaning down, his lips touch yours. He starts to pull away then, but you wrap your arms around him. He pauses, his lips still on yours, and then leans in. You run your hands through his hair, and Ethan scoops you up. He crushes you against his chest, still kissing you. Then he sits on the couch with you on his lap, and you press your lips on his, and the kiss is wild, and passionate. Ethan slides his hands up your back, and around your neck. Finally, you break apart, and relax on the couch.
  19. Caleb pokes his head in the door. "Um, guys? Dinner's ready!" You nod, and stand up. Ethan stands, too, and takes your hand. Caleb's face becomes dark. Ethan grins at him, and you give him an 'I'm sorry' face. Caleb frowns, but follows you and Ethan to the dining room. Dinner is delicious, warm spaghetti and spicy meatballs. Ethan sits next to you, Caleb is on the other side of you, and Josh sits across the table with his head down.
  20. Suddenly, an explosion rocked the house. Caleb grabbed you, and ran through a tunnel in the kitchen. "Wait! Ethan and Josh!" you cry out. "They'll be fine. RUN!" yells Caleb. You do, and finally make it outside. Together,you huddle under an oak tree, and wait for the guys. Finally they emerge- Ethan is leaning on Josh and is bloodied. "Monster...get away," he mumbles. Josh pulls out a tiny device and catches Ethan up in a glowing green net. He floats along behind you as you run. Finally, you settle down for the night. You curl up in a ball against a maple tree and fall asleep. In the morning when you wake up, all the guys are gone. You sit up, and a dark shape comes through the trees toward you. "Ethan?" you ask. The figure comes closer, and you realize that its not human at all. It has a hideous face and long arms. You start to stand, but the creature runs to you. It bites your arm, hard, and you black out.
  21. CLIFF HANGER!!!!!!!!!!!!! come back for my next one, coming out soon!

Remember to rate this quiz on the next page!
Rating helps us to know which quizzes are good and which are bad.

Related Quizzes:

What is GotoQuiz? A better kind of quiz site: no pop-ups, no registration requirements, just high-quality quizzes that you can create and share on your social network. Have a look around and see what we're about.