Case 2: The Deadly Valentine

Quiz Image

Hey guys this is Case 2: The Deadly Valentine. For the newcomers, please read Case 1: The Boy on the Ledge so you'll understand this series. It can be found on my page!You will actually have to solve this case! Don't worry I will tell you who the culprit is as the ending result. Some cases will have the culprit as a result and other cases will have the guys as multiple results. You will also learn more about Chris' past in this part.

Here are the guy's descriptions: Johnny Milano - short black hair and light blue eyes. Alex Pike - brown hair and deep blue eyes. Chris Hartwell - dirty blonde hair and brown eyes. Bryan Porter - shaggy black hair and green eyes. Please read the case carefully. Happy Reading :D

Created by: Jinx_TheSleuth

Are you ready for...
Our "When Will I Die" Quiz?

  1. ~6:55 AM Monday Morning~ You wake up to hear your favorite song on your bedside alarm. You turn it off. "Ugh it's 6:55." you mumble. You were not a morning person. You wake up but don't recognize where you are. You forgot that you're in your new bedroom...at your new house...in Gwenville. You and your family moved to the small town of Gwenville right outside Patriarch City. It's been two days since you met four interesting guys. You never thought you'd meet Johnny Milano and Alex Pike at a crime scene. That same day you met Chris Hartwell because you witnessed his poor mother being shot by a mysterious man. And after that, you met Bryan Porter, a hot doctor from the UK. You go on your bedroom balcony to see the sunrise until you hear a knock on your door.
  2. "Come in!" you say. Your mom walks in with a heart shape balloon and a box of chocolates. "Happy Valentines Day sweetie!"your mom say. You facepalm because you forgot it was February 14th! Your parents always gave you and your little brother gifts on Valentines Day. "Thanks mom. I forgot about today." you said. "It's OK Hun. You had a lot on your mind since that poor lady was gun down the other day." she said. Her sentence made you shiver inside. Chris' poor mom just laid there in her own blood. And that evil man saw you witness the murder. His smile haunts you in your daydream. "Sweetie are you alright?" your mom snapped her fingers in front of you. You instantly snapped back to reality. "Yea I'm fine. What's for breakfast?" you ask. "I made your father's favorite Valentines breakfast: chocolate chip pancakes!" You were relieved because that's your favorite breakfast too! "Well, get dress and come eat breakfast because you have to take your brother to school today." she walked out the room. You already graduated from high school but you still had to take your brother to school. He's in the tenth grade. You remember when you were in the tenth grade. Those were the worst days of your life. You decide to take a shower before you eat. When you got out the shower, you straighten your hair and wear:
  3. You change into your clothes and head downstairs. You walk into the dining room and see your brother eating a stack of pancakes. "What's up" he says. You give him the nod and grab a plate. You and your brother always had a great sibling relationship. You got along well with each other. As you talk about random things your dad walks in tying his tie. He works for this big finance company that you can't remember the name of. That's half the reason why you moved here. The other reason was kind of your fault. You were a trouble maker in your old town, Oakville. So your parents thought this could be a good fresh start for you. They were pretty right. After all you did meet four new friends. "Hey guys! Did you get the gifts?" your dad asked. "Yeah! Thanks!" you and your brother said at the same time. Your dad began eating 6 pancakes at the same time. "Slow down babe," your mom said to your dad walking in with the house phone in her hand, "______ you have someone on the phone for you. You got up and wondered who it was. You only knew four people in the whole city. "H-hello?" you stuttered. "I know who you are and I know what you saw. If you help out Inspector Maguire with the Hartwell case, you and your family will regret it." You panicked. His voice sounded muffled out like he didn't want anyone to recognize him –-- of course."Who are you! And how did you get my number!?!?!" you yelled. "Honey is everything alright?" your mom yelled from the other room. "Don't tell anyone I called." he hung up. This was definitely a male voice and then you thought: *This may be the guy in the red trench coat that shot Chris' mom. I guess I was the only witness* Your brother came in the living room holding his book bag. "Ready to go?" he said. "Yeah" you replied and grabbed your motorcycle keys.
  4. You pull your black CB1000 out of the garage and you look around nervously to see if anyone is watching you. Your brother hops on and you head to his new school. His school is in the city. When you get there, everyone is staring at the two of you when you take off your helmet. "I will see you at 4 OK." you tell your brother. He nods and walks inside. Before you could put your helmet back on, a hand grabs your shoulder and you swiftly turn around. "What are you doing here?" you ask Chris. He's looking extremely hot today because he's wearing a black suit and red tie. "Hey," he says, "It's career day at the high school and they asked me to talk about the company." he smiles and stares at you up and down. "I didn't know you ride a motorcycle. I like a dangerous girl." he winks at you. "I have to go." you lied. You didn't have anywhere else to go. You were actually planning on watching TV all day. "Do you want to join me? It will just be from 8 to 10." he asked. "I don't know..." you said, playing hard to get. "I will buy you lunch afterward." he said. "Count me in!" you jump off your bike and follow him into the school. "It's not everyday you get to hang out with a multimillionaire." He winks and you just roll your eyes.
  5. ~12:00 AM "The Year of the Dragon Chinese Buffet"~ You and Chris are sitting at a table at your new favorite Chinese restaurant. "Chris? Can we talk about your childhood now?" you ask. "Um sure," he said, "What do you want to know?" "Everything." you replied. "OK. I'm an only child. My parents separated when I was ten. A week after my sixteenth birthday, my dad died and left his company to me." he explained. Chris owns his father's company, Newwave Technologies. They sale the best hi-tech cellphones and laptops. "So, as the years passed and business started booming, I stopped talking to my mom and started talking to the wrong people. I dated the sluttiest girls and regretted a lot of things. I wanted to tell my mom I love her but I never built up the courage to call her." he said. "I'm sorry you didn't get to tell your mom how you really felt." you said. "It's OK. I know she was really proud of me. And besides, I met you." you blushed. You look around the restaurant and notice it's very empty.
  6. There's only three other people in here. There were two guys and one girl sitting at the table across from you and Chris. One guy is super buff. He has short dark brown hair and brown eyes. The other guy looks a bit nerdy but cute. He has thick glasses on but behind those glasses are beautiful light blue eyes. The girl was really pretty. She had long black hair and striking green eyes. You could over hear their whole conversation. The buff guy was trying to push up on the pretty girl. "I don't understand why you don't want me Jen," he said, "Come on, it's Valentines Day. How about a kiss." He leaned over to the girl but she pushed him away. "Leave me alone Randy!" she yelled. "Whatever..." he said. The nerdy looking guy had his head buried in a chemistry book, but he had an annoyed look on his face. "He must be really into that book." Chris said looking at you. "Yeah he is. And that Randy guy is so annoying." you said. Two more people walked in. A girl with short blond hair and dark blue eyes and a guy that had shoulder length black hair and amber eyes. "Hey Sarah & Nick!" Jen said. I guess they were all meeting up with each other. Sarah and Nick sat down with the rest of the group. You and Chris kept eating and talking. But you just had a bad feeling about the group of friends sitting across from you. So you eavesdropped.
  7. ~The Group's Point of View~ "Is anyone going to eat?" Randy asked while eating a plateful of everything. That's when everyone got up and grabbed a plate. They sat back down and started eating. "Sarah, is that all your eating?" Jen asked. Sarah just had spinach on her plate and nothing else. "Ugh I hate spinach" Nick said. Everyone else agreed. "It looks like Sarah wants to change her image. Don't worry babe your not my type anyway." Randy said. "Shut up Randy! Why do you have to be such a jerk." Danny (the nerdy guy) said. Randy stood up. "You got something to say loser?!?!?" Danny put his head down. "That's what I thought!" "Everyone just calm down. Are we going to eat the Valentines Day candy or not?" Nick said trying to calm things down. "Yeah, everyone brought the same kind right?" Jen asked. Everyone nodded and took out their Valentines Day chocolate box except for Sarah and Jen. "I left mine in the car." Jen said. She walked out to go get it. "I have to go to the bathroom." Sarah said. Jen came back in with her chocolate box. There were five chocolate boxes on the table. "I didn't bring any chocolate." Sarah said. "Why not? You always bring chocolate candy on our annual Valentines Day lunch." Danny said. "I-I just think it's childish." Sarah said. "We've been doing this ever since we were kids. It's tradition." Jen said. "I JUST DON'T WANT TO EAT ANYTHING!" Sarah shouted. "Fine..." Jen replied. There were a lot of tension between the two. "Let's start eating!" Randy said. He grabbed the first piece of candy and popped it in his mouth. Before anyone could eat any he started coughing and wailing. "WHAT'S WRONG WITH HIM!?!?!?" Nick yelled. "Someone call 911! He's choking." Jen said panicking. It was too late.
  8. ~Your P.O.V~ You're talking with Chris and you suddenly see the Randy guy fall over. You immediately call Milano and Pike. "Who's messing up my sleep?' Pike answered. "Hey Pike! I need your help. A guy just collapsed on the floor!" you said. "Where are you?!?!?" Pike asked. "I'm at The Year of the Dragon. Hurry up and call for back up." you said. "We're on the way. Make sure no one touches the body." he hung up. You run over to the group and tell everyone to back up. Chris runs over to calm everyone down. You look at Randy's face and see that his lips are purple. Then, you look over to see Sarah hand Jen some candy. You knock the candy out of their hands. "Don't eat the candy." you said. "Why? He only choked on the candy." Jen said. "No, he was poisoned." you said. "How do you know?" Nick said. "His lips are very purple and there is nothing blocking his esophagus." you explained. Milano and Pike walked in with Inspector Maguire and Bryan. "Hey ________. They all said at the same time giving each other looks that said back off. "Hey guys." you said. "So the young fellow name is Randy Echols. It looks like he choked on this piece of candy." Inspector Maguire said. "Yes sir. But he didn't choke on the candy; he was poisoned." you said. "She's right. He was poisoned." Bryan said inspecting the body. He gave you a small smirk. "I've never met a girl as smart and beautiful as you." his British accent made you tremble in a good way. "Enough with the flirting," Milano interrupted. You can't believe he was jealous. "The real question is, who did it?" Pike asked. "Me and ___________ concluded it was one of the four standing before us." Chris said.
  9. "How could it be one of us?" Nick asked. "You guys do this every year right? And you eat the same type of candy every year right?" you asked. They all nodded in agreement. "Then someone knew this was the right opportunity to kill Randy. And you all held a grudge against him. Didn't you." You said. "I didn't hold a grudge against Randy." Nick said. "Yes you did," Sarah said, "Two years ago, your girlfriend left you for Randy. You were so broken up about it you haven't talked to us in months." Sarah said. "Yeah but I got over it."What about Jen? He was always pushing up on you. You could have easily poisoned him when you left to go get the chocolate." Nick said. "I didn't kill him." Jen said afraid. "You hated his guts." Nick said. "Of course I did. We all did. But that doesn't mean I wanted to poison him. That's terrible." she said. You observed everyone. Jen looked like she was about to cry. She had her head on Danny's shoulder. And then you looked over at Nick. He was staring at Sarah with sympathy. Sarah was biting her nails nervously. Danny was tapping his foot impatiently. "I know who the murderer is," you said, "The murderer is you..."
  10. CLIFFHANGER!!! It's not really a cliffhanger. Submit your results and you'll see who did it!I want to know if your accusation was right. So please comment and rate!!!

Remember to rate this quiz on the next page!
Rating helps us to know which quizzes are good and which are bad.

Related Quizzes:

What is GotoQuiz? A better kind of quiz site: no pop-ups, no registration requirements, just high-quality quizzes that you can create and share on your social network. Have a look around and see what we're about.